Other State Solutions for Redistricting

Solution in Selected States: 
Legislature Alone
Summary of Solution: 


Commissions with Primary Responsibility for Drawing a Plan


Number of Members

Selection Requirements

Formation Date

Initial Deadline

Final Deadline


Alaska Const. art. 6


Governor appoints two; then president of the Senate appoints one; then speaker of the House appoints one; then chief justice of the Supreme Court appoints one. At least one member must be a resident of each judicial district. No member may be a public employee or official.

By September 1, 2010

30 days after census officially reported

90 days after census officially reported


Ariz. Const. art. 4, pt. 2, § 1


The commission on appellate court appointees creates a pool of 25 nominees, ten from each of the two largest parties and five not from either of the two largest parties. The highest ranking officer of the house appoints one from the pool, then the minority leader of the house appoints one, then the highest ranking officer of the senate appoints one, then the minority leader of the senate appoints one. These four appoint a fifth from the pool, not a member of any party already represented on the commission, as chair. If the four deadlock, the commission on appellate court appointments appoints the chair.

By February 28, 2011




Ark. Const. 1874, art. 8


Commission consists of the governor, secretary of state, and the attorney general


By February 1, 2011

Plan becomes official 30 days after it is filed


Article XXI




With the Passage of Proposition 11 in 2008, the process of redrawing California's state legislative districts was removed from state legislative authority and given to a newly established 14 member commission.  The commission must include 5 Democrats, 5 Republicans, and 4 members from neither party.  Government auditors are to select 60 registered voters from an applicant pool.  Legislative leaders can reduce the pool; the auditors then are to pick eight commission members by lottery, and those commissioners pick six additional members for 14 total.  For approval district boundaries need votes from three Democratic commissioners, three Republican commissioners, and three commissioners from neither party.By December 31, 2010 and each year ending in the number zero thereafterNoneBy September 15, 2011 and in each year ending in the number 1 thereafter


Colo. Const. art. V, § 48


Legislature selects four: (speaker of the House; House minority leader; Senate majority and minority leaders; or their delegates). Governor selects three. Judiciary selects four. Maximum of four from the legislature. Each congressional district must have at least one person, but no more than four people representing it on the commission. At least one member must live west of the Continental Divide.

By August 1, 2011

90 days after the availability of the census data, or after the formation of the committee, whichever is later

March 15, 2012


Haw. Const. art. IV


President of the Senate selects two. Speaker of the House selects two. Minority senate party selects two. These eight select the ninth member, who is the chair. No commission member may run for the legislature in the two elections following redistricting.

By March 1, 2011

80 days after the commission forms 

150 days after commission formation


Idaho Const. art. III, § 2


Leaders of two largest political parties in each house of the legislature each designate one member; chairs of the two parties whose candidates for governor received the most votes in the last election each designate one member. No member may be an elected or appointed official in the state at the time of designation.

Within 15 days after the secretary of state orders creation of a commission


90 days after the commission is organized, or after census data is receive, whichever is later


Mo. Const. art. III, § 2

House: 18 Senate: 10

There are two separate redistricting committees. Governor picks one person from each list of two submitted by the two main political parties in each congressional district to form the house committee. Governor picks five people from two lists of 10 submitted by the two major political parties in the state to form the senate committee. No commission member may hold office in the legislature for four years after redistricting. 

Within 60 days of the census data becoming available

Five months after the commission forms

Six months after formation


Mont. Const. art. V, § 14


Majority and minority leaders of both houses of the Legislature each select one member. Those four select a fifth, who is the chair. Members cannot be public officials. Members cannot run for public office in the two years after the completion of redistricting.

The legislative session before the census data is available

The commission must give the plan to the Legislature at the first regular session after its appointment

30 days after the plan is returned by the Legislature

New Jersey

N.J. Const. art. IV, § 3


The chairs of the two major parties each select five members. If these 10 members cannot develop a plan in the allotted time, the chief justice of the state Supreme Court will appoint an 11th member. 

December 1, 2010

February 1, 2011, or one month after the census data becomes available

The initial deadline, or one month after the 11th member is picked


Ohio Const. art. XI


Board consists of the governor, auditor, secretary of state, and two people selected by the legislative leaders of each major political party.

Between August 1 and October 1, 2011


October 5, 2011


Pa. Const. art. II, § 17


Majority and minority leaders of the legislative houses each select one member. These four select a fifth to chair. If they fail to do so within 45 days, a majority of the state Supreme Court will select the fifth member. The chair cannot be a public official.

None listed

90 days after the availability of the census data or after commission formation, whichever is later

30 days after the last public exception that is filed against the initial plan


Wash. Const. art. II, § 43


Majority and minority leaders of the House and Senate each select one. These four select a non-voting fifth to chair the commission. If they fail to do so by January 1, 2001, the state Supreme Court will select the fifth by February 5, 2001. No commission member may be a public official.

January 31, 2011


January 1, 2012





A Project of the Howard Samuels New York Policy Center, Inc.
Web Development by Kallos Consulting 

Creative Commons License